If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
Agonising over the Canons S3 IS, S5 IS or the Sony H9.
Any opinions welcome before I buy. Amateur but fussy general use. JB |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
On Tue, 15 May 2007 13:28:57 +0100, Jackson Bryan wrote:
Agonising over the Canons S3 IS, S5 IS or the Sony H9. Any opinions welcome before I buy. Amateur but fussy general use. JB Suggest you also look at Kodak P series. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
The S5 will not be shipping until June. Reviews should be out by then.
It seems to have more features than the S3. I am agonizing between the S5 (assuming that the image quality is good) and the Panasonic FZ8. Reviews say the FZ8 has noisy images but the camera is great. The main problem with all of the reviews is that they do not have detailed head to head reviews (especially as to image quality and camera performance; one can easily compare features) between cameras that people will choose between. Maybe they do not want to upset their advertisers. Jackson Bryan wrote: Agonising over the Canons S3 IS, S5 IS or the Sony H9. Any opinions welcome before I buy. Amateur but fussy general use. JB |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
"measekite" wrote in message t... The S5 will not be shipping until June. Reviews should be out by then. It seems to have more features than the S3. I am agonizing between the S5 (assuming that the image quality is good) and the Panasonic FZ8. Reviews say the FZ8 has noisy images but the camera is great. How can a camera be 'great' and have noisy images? Ron The main problem with all of the reviews is that they do not have detailed head to head reviews (especially as to image quality and camera performance; one can easily compare features) between cameras that people will choose between. Maybe they do not want to upset their advertisers. Jackson Bryan wrote: Agonising over the Canons S3 IS, S5 IS or the Sony H9. Any opinions welcome before I buy. Amateur but fussy general use. JB |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
Ron Recer wrote:
[] How can a camera be 'great' and have noisy images? Ron Ron, All cameras produce noisy images! A camera may seem to be "noisy" by having less noise-reduction processing imposed on the images by default (in comparison with the competition) - i.e. leaving you more in control. David |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
Canon S5 IS nyday...
1) Its a CANON (this itself is a very srong point o its own) 2) Sony uses very high Noise reduction when shooting in High ISO thus resulting in blurring of the images 3) High Fringing of images (even though fringing is visible in Canon but is relativelly less) 4) The DIGIC III processor it uses is far superior in its class. 5) Sony offers high ISO (upto 3200) which is good in some cases but also increases the Noise in the image... if u compare the Canon s3 IS to the s5IS ... there is no significant improvent which i believe Canon should have given.. just some Megapixels improvement and the size of LCD is not good enough to justify an cost escalation of $200.. i hope this helps... P.S. Sony H9 is also in the same price range that of S5...so according to me it should be the S5 Regards On May 15, 4:28 am, "Jackson Bryan" wrote: Agonising over the Canons S3 IS, S5 IS or the Sony H9. Any opinions welcome before I buy. Amateur but fussy general use. JB |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
On May 16, 12:58 am, measekite wrote:
I am agonizing between the S5 (assuming that the image quality is good) and the Panasonic FZ8. Gee... Just go to the store and try them in your hands. You will see at once if you like the camera or dislike it. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
On Jun 25, 1:39 am, wrote:
1) Its a CANON (this itself is a very srong point o its own) Not necessarily. I agree a Canon camera is likely to make good quality pictures. They look good. However, when I take a Canon camera in my hands (e.g. in the camera shop or at work), I feel disconnected from the aesthetics of physical appearance of the camera. The ergonomics of the camera (how the knobs operate the camera) looks to me unappealing. But I have made an emotional connection with a Panasonic camera. That's the most important factor to decide when choosing the camera. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Canon S5 IS or Sony H9?
On Jun 25, 5:31 am, carrera d'olbani wrote:
On Jun 25, 1:39 am, wrote: 1) Its a CANON (this itself is a very srong point o its own) Not necessarily. I agree a Canon camera is likely to make good quality pictures. They look good. However, when I take a Canon camera in my hands (e.g. in the camera shop or at work), I feel disconnected from the aesthetics of physical appearance of the camera. The ergonomics of the camera (how the knobs operate the camera) looks to me unappealing. But I have made an emotional connection with a Panasonic camera. That's the most important factor to decide when choosing the camera. i am more practical when buying electronics not emotional... when i get the best( atleast i think), then i get emotionally attached to it... Panasonic is also very good in image quality but the noise levels aree high compared to the canon.. Nix |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
TESTS; Nikon D80, Canon Rebel XTi, Sony A100, Canon 30D | RichA | Digital SLR Cameras | 2 | October 14th 06 02:53 AM |
Images; Sony A100 ver Nikon D80 ver Canon Rebel XTi ver Canon 30D | Rich | Digital Photography | 0 | October 13th 06 07:45 PM |
CANON S3 or SONY H5 ? | Talal Itani | Digital Point & Shoot Cameras | 7 | August 25th 06 04:34 PM |
Canon S80, Sony DSC-N1, Canon A620 or Sony Cybershot P200 | [email protected] | Digital Photography | 9 | January 6th 06 04:21 AM |
Canon A95 vs Sony w1 vs Canon IXUS 500 | MaXimus | Digital Photography | 0 | December 8th 04 10:13 PM |