If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Pairs comments - Alan B.
"otter" wrote in message ... On Aug 1, 10:32 am, Savageduck wrote: On 2012-08-01 06:35:44 -0700, otter said: [ ... ] ...but maybe I will just wait this time to see what comments appear. -- Regards, Savageduck Group dynamics are not the same as a computer program. No one is going to read my comments and follow them literally, with step by step consequences. There are several SI contributers that have a long history of posting pictures but no comments. My take is that they are not interested so much in critique, but in seeing their pictures displayed. I think many of those are not all that interested in "improving", and/or simply disregard comments anyway. I also think you over-value comments in regards to the success of the SI, but I'm not going to campaign for eliminating them. If it make people happy to do it, fine with me. When I look at the submissions to SI the comments spring to mind, ready-made; I regard verbalizing them for the Group as a chore. Unlike many chores, there are no significant consequences if the chore is put off or ignored. So, sometimes I don't do the comment chore for every image, or for any image. Sometimes I think it is enough to point out what it is about an image that rings my bell; sometimes I think such comments are re-stating the obvious, so I don't offer them. It is not important enough to me that others either enjoy or benefit from my perceptions of their works, that I will sacrifice a lot of comfort to fulfill their needs. Sloth is a great motivator. I overcome it from time to time and comment on every image as a result of obligation to others who do make sincere, thoughtful comments about everyone's images, my images, or a few random images. The Social Contract at work. I do not feel or infer a great drive to have my images or comments seen by others, and especially I don't think it is important to share every thought I have about everything that passes through my field of apprehension. There is usually only room for one Bloviator-in-Chief in any given group. I have neither the interest nor the stamina (or maybe the discernment) to try correcting every error or misstep I see in a group. Not my job, maing. One of the pass-times we in my family indulge in is to make up stories that explain noticeable events, e.g.: "Look at that numskull! He must never have learned what courtesy and consideration are!" "Yeah, or he saw you coming and, figuring you are alert and attentive and wouldn't run into him, decided it was OK to pull out in front of you so you had to slam on the brakes to avoid running into him." "Yeah, that too. Maybe he just didn't see us?" /etc./ "Why do I have to try explaining everything? I dunno. Maybe I get it from my Mom: she was always explaining things". You don't have to look very far in this/these forums to find a whole lot of explainers, some of whom disguise the impulse under several layers of dissimulation or misdirection. In the worst cases every one-note song becomes instantly recognizable. After a while it all stops being useful, if it ever was, or entertaining, ditto, and becomes so tedious as to result in avoidance, aka plonk. I would not stop submitting to, or viewing the submissions to, the SI if all commenting was gone. My comments will still be there in my mind, which will not be enough for some; I take comfort in the assumption that others are similarly afflicted, and won't be completely frustrated if they, too, reserve them for themselves. A little disappointed, though. -- Frank ess |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
[SI] Pairs comments - Alan B. | PeterN[_2_] | 35mm Photo Equipment | 45 | August 10th 12 09:55 PM |
Pairs comments - Alan B. | Frank S | Digital Photography | 0 | August 2nd 12 07:43 PM |
[SI] Pairs etc - Eric Stevens comments | Eric Stevens | 35mm Photo Equipment | 35 | July 24th 12 01:04 AM |