If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Nikon D50, worth it, or go higher?
OK...my trusted little Nikon Coolpix 5700 has finally bit the dust
and joined the ranks of Ansel Adams, Helmut Newton, and Jimi Hendrix in that great big digital darkroom in the sky. moment of silence After over a year of dreaming, teasing myself, and talking about it endlessly, I am now ready to jump on that dSLR bandwagon. I already own a low-end Nikon film SLR, and a few consumer lenses. I'm not heavily invested into the Nikon system, but I tend to think of myself as a Nikon guy (but I can be persuaded otherwise). long-winded drivel finished Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? I'm 90% ready to place my order, but I'm looking for some last minute comments :-) -- Bill |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Woodchuck Bill wrote: [ ... ] After over a year of dreaming, teasing myself, and talking about it endlessly, I am now ready to jump on that dSLR bandwagon. I already own a low-end Nikon film SLR, and a few consumer lenses. I'm not heavily invested into the Nikon system, but I tend to think of myself as a Nikon guy (but I can be persuaded otherwise). Are these lenses autofocus ones? (Was your camera body an autofocus one?) [ ... ] Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. I got my D70 a bit over a year ago, with a nice Nikkor 28-105mm f3.5-4.5D already in hand so I bought body only. I recently went back and bought the "kit" lens for the D70 (18-70mm f3.5-4.5) after reading some very high opinions of it, and deciding that I really *did* need the extra width after taking the 1.5 crop factor into account. The D70 (and D70s) kit lens will give you about the same coverage with the 1.5 crop factor as your 28-105 gives on film. So if you are accustomed to the 28-105, and actually *use* the wide angle end of its range, you really will want the wider kit lens. Note that the D50 comes with two kit lenses, which cover a lesser range each. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? When I decided to buy a digital Nikon (the only choice for me, with all the Nikkor glass which I already had), I spent some time reading the reviews of the D100 and the D70, and I decided that the D70 did more of what I wanted, even though it cost less. (I did not at the time realize that the D100 was nearing the end of its product life, but just decided based on the features of the two.) The D50 is supposed to have most of the features of the D70, but there are a couple which I could not do without -- including a simple thing like a button to illuminate the controls display on top of the camera for setting in low light conditions. Another factor is the lack of the second command dial (under the shutter button on the front of the camera), which makes some of the manual controls more awkward, if you are using them. The D50 appears to have a smaller (and darker) viewfinder than the D70 (based on a recent look through one in the camera store as I was placing my order for the kit lens). If you are going to be using it in plenty of light, this probably does not matter, but if you like to take photos in low light, it certainly will. (Now granted, it could be that the camera had no battery (or an under-charged battery) installed, and was just not controlling the lens' aperture properly -- but I think that in the absence of power, the lens should go to maximum aperture. The D50 is also *physically* smaller than the D70 and D70s. You should probably go to your camera store and handle both, to see which one feels most comfortable to you. I have read here reports of people comparing the D70 to the Cannon Digital Rebel, and being that close to buying the Cannon, until they handled both, and found the D70 to be a more natural fit in their hands. (This is contrasted with another poster here, who came from a Point-and-Shoot background, who found the same Digital Rebel to feel too large and heavy, and who therefore would have been even more unhappy with the D70, or any of Nikon's or Cannon's higher end cameras. :-) I think that I, personally, would still go for the D70 (actually the D70s now) if I were to have to re-make my purchase at this time. (I would *really* like to have the D2x, but I can't afford that one. :-) The D70 is within my price range. Note that there are adaptors to allow you to use your Nikon glass on a Cannon (in manual mode only, with stop-down metering), but there are not adaptors to allow you to use Cannon glass on a Nikon body. If you want the automation of the camera to be used to best effect, you will want the manufacturer's own glass on the camera -- or at least others which are designed to work with that camera. Also, I have heard here that some of the third-party makers of glass for Nikons have problems with the older lenses needing their firmware upgraded to work with the newer cameras, because the makers tried to reverse-engineer the interface, instead of paying the license fee and getting the full information. This may or may not apply to whatever third-party 28-105mm lens you happen to have. I'm 90% ready to place my order, but I'm looking for some last minute comments :-) Well -- you have my thoughts as a happy owner of a D70. You might as well wait to see what others say. But remember to try all the candidates before committing. (It is for things like this that you support a local camera store instead of going to mail-order places, which *can't* let you try out cameras in the store. :-) Enjoy, DoN. -- Email: | Voice (all times): (703) 938-4564 (too) near Washington D.C. | http://www.d-and-d.com/dnichols/DoN.html --- Black Holes are where God is dividing by zero --- |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Woodchuck Bill wrote:
Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? The D50 is entry level. Ask yourself if the idea of using an "entry level" SLR is something you find comfortable, or objectionable. If the latter, go with the D70. If the former, try a D50 in the store just to make sure it doesn't feel too small in your hands. The D70 is pretty small as SLRs go, but it's not "small". Get the 18-70 kit lens, not the shorter/cheaper one. While I have no idea how the new/shorter/cheaper one is, the 18-70 is a very nice lens and it'll get you the wide angle that you won't have with your existing lenses. Don't skimp on lenses; you will have them a lot longer than you'll have the camera body. If your existing lenses are not autofocus, you probably won't want to use them on either a D70 or a D50 because the light meter won't function. If they are autofocus, they will be fine. The 50mm in particular is a great lens, and I find it much more useful on digital (with the 1.5x crop) than on full-frame film. Adding the 18-70 to what you've got will give you all the glass you need to get started. -- Jeremy | |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Woodchuck Bill wrote:
OK...my trusted little Nikon Coolpix 5700 has finally bit the dust and joined the ranks of Ansel Adams, Helmut Newton, and Jimi Hendrix in that great big digital darkroom in the sky. moment of silence After over a year of dreaming, teasing myself, and talking about it endlessly, I am now ready to jump on that dSLR bandwagon. I already own a low-end Nikon film SLR, and a few consumer lenses. I'm not heavily invested into the Nikon system, but I tend to think of myself as a Nikon guy (but I can be persuaded otherwise). long-winded drivel finished Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? I'm 90% ready to place my order, but I'm looking for some last minute comments :-) Should you want to stay point-and-shoot (and save on subsequent lens purchases), you can get a 5700-like camera, lighter, more zoom, image stabilisation, in the Panasonic FZ5. Of course, the DSLR will give you a higher ultimate quality, but you could get a lot of fun from the FZ5 for less than the outlay of a D50. Cheers, David |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
"Woodchuck Bill" wrote in message . .. OK...my trusted little Nikon Coolpix 5700 has finally bit the dust and joined the ranks of Ansel Adams, Helmut Newton, and Jimi Hendrix in that great big digital darkroom in the sky. moment of silence After over a year of dreaming, teasing myself, and talking about it endlessly, I am now ready to jump on that dSLR bandwagon. I already own a low-end Nikon film SLR, and a few consumer lenses. I'm not heavily invested into the Nikon system, but I tend to think of myself as a Nikon guy (but I can be persuaded otherwise). long-winded drivel finished Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? I'm 90% ready to place my order, but I'm looking for some last minute comments :-) Just to add to what has already been mentioned... The D50 uses SD Card and not Compact Flash. So you can re-use your CF cards on a D70/s. I have a D70 and very happy with it. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Woodchuck Bill" wrote in message . .. OK...my trusted little Nikon Coolpix 5700 has finally bit the dust and joined the ranks of Ansel Adams, Helmut Newton, and Jimi Hendrix in that great big digital darkroom in the sky. moment of silence After over a year of dreaming, teasing myself, and talking about it endlessly, I am now ready to jump on that dSLR bandwagon. I already own a low-end Nikon film SLR, and a few consumer lenses. I'm not heavily invested into the Nikon system, but I tend to think of myself as a Nikon guy (but I can be persuaded otherwise). long-winded drivel finished Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? I'm 90% ready to place my order, but I'm looking for some last minute comments :-) -- Bill I'd say only you can decide if it's worth it to you. The DSLRs from the big brands, Canon, Nikon etc are pretty similar technically and you should be more influenced by the 'look and feel' and features you like, and the accessories eg lens you have invested in. Overall the D50 is 'similar' to the 350D (Rebel XT), and some on here will argue for their favourite. Kit lenses get unjustified bad press in my view, as they can offer good value if you need a lens. Where do you get an equivalent for £/$100 ?. Going to higher models, D70/s or 20D, will give you better performance and features, but you know how much you are willing to spend. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
In article , Woodchuck
Bill wrote: Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? I'm 90% ready to place my order, but I'm looking for some last minute comments :-) My two thoughts: 1. Never buy the cheapest model of ANYTHING - they're going to cut corners to get that price as low as possible. (The corollary is to never buy the top of the line - they're adding fluff to justify the top price). 2. If you've never owned an item in the product category before, don't sweat the choice too much - you don't yet know what features are important to YOU. Just buy one and work with it a while. The NEXT one you buy will be the keeper. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Per Woodchuck Bill:
Do I buy the D50? Body only, or kit? I already have a 50mm prime and a 28-105 consumer zoom. I know...this won't give me much on the wide end. Should I go with a slightly more expensive model...either Nikon or another brand? When I shopped my D70s a few weeks ago, it seemed like going with the body/lens bundle was the no-brainier price wise. I went for the 18-70 based on various recommendations that Google found. I also sprang for the little $17.00 infra red remote and a $14.00 el-cheapo Tiffen "filter" (quotes bc all it does is protect the lens). -- PeteCresswell |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
(PeteCresswell) wrote: Per Jeremy Nixon: Get the 18-70 kit lens, not the shorter/cheaper one. While I have no idea how the new/shorter/cheaper one is, the 18-70 is a very nice lens and it'll get you the wide angle that you won't The 50mm in particular is a great lens, and I find it much more useful on digital Question from a newbie: given that I have an 18-70 zoom, what would a 50mm lens do for me? Higher speeds? Significantly better rez? As a D70 user with the 50mm f1.4, the 18-70 kit lens, and the 28-105mm lens (plus a 180mm f2.8 non AF, but which has been modified to have a CPU chip allowing the TTL metering to work), I find the 50mm has the following advantages: 1) In low light, the autofocus is faster. 2) In low light, you can use lower ISO settings, or higher shutter speeds (or often both, as you have about three stops over the best that the kit lens will do). 3) In low light, you can see to frame and focus through the viewfinder much better. 4) The effective coverage of a 50mm on the D70 (equivalent to a 75mm on a 35mm film camera) is nice for some portrait work. 50mm on film is too close, and leads to uncomfortable perspective distortion at a frame-filling distance. 5) With a f1.4 maximum aperture, it is easier to throw backgrounds and foregrounds out of focus, to keep the viewer's attention where you want it to be. 6) The camera weighs less for walk-around shooting with this lens fitted. Something which can become important if you are walking a lot. 7) It is a useful bit of discipline to be able to compose and shoot without having a zoom. It can change the way you view things. 8) When the camera is hung around my neck and one arm on a strap, it is possible to protect the lens in the crook of my elbow, so when walking in a crowd, or through narrow spaces, I can protect both the lens and the camera. (I keep a collapsible rubber lens hood on that lens.) The 28-105mm is long enough so it extends beyond the protecting arm. The 18-70mm is closer to being protected, except that the lens hood extends beyond the protection zone, unless it is stored reversed. And, unlike with the lens hood for the 28-105mm stored reversed, I can't reach the zoom control with the hood stored reversed, so I tend to have it stored in normal position when it is on the camera. So -- it depends on how I feel on a given day. I will walk around with either the 28-105mm, the 50mm, or the 18-70mm, leaving all of the other lenses in the camera bag. Or -- sometimes, I will bring the whole camera bag and struggle to walk. :-) Good Luck, DoN. -- Email: | Voice (all times): (703) 938-4564 (too) near Washington D.C. | http://www.d-and-d.com/dnichols/DoN.html --- Black Holes are where God is dividing by zero --- |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
(PeteCresswell) wrote:
Question from a newbie: given that I have an 18-70 zoom, what would a 50mm lens do for me? Higher speeds? Significantly better rez? Both of the above, in large quantity. It's also a very different shooting experience, freeing yourself from screwing around with a zoom. -- Jeremy | |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Nikon Coolpix 5700 severe flash underexposure problem | All Things Mopar | Digital Photography | 21 | November 2nd 04 05:38 AM |
Nikon 35mm and APS SLRs and related equipment for sale | Mike Schnierle | 35mm Equipment for Sale | 0 | October 29th 03 04:44 PM |
Nikon F4s, F90x, 20,60,85,105,35-70,80-200 | tony | 35mm Equipment for Sale | 0 | October 19th 03 10:17 PM |
FS: Nikon F3 | OF | 35mm Equipment for Sale | 0 | September 25th 03 04:12 PM |
FS: Nikon F4, Nikkor Lens and accessories. | FocaIPoint | General Equipment For Sale | 0 | August 23rd 03 01:36 AM |