If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
SI - Work - Comments
On 3/24/2012 2:53 PM, tony cooper wrote:
I mostly agree with your comments, but I am too lazy to repeat name and, except where noted I don't have much to add to your comments: FrankEss-worka: Far too cluttered. No one would ever guess the subject is "work". FrankEss-workb: I dunno if this says "work', but it's an interesting scene. Too me it's a representation of work. Nice presentation of the art of others. ?-Amateur physicist: Really interesting project. Full credit for imagination. Nice capture. the facial expression says work. Savageduck-(Genius Bar): Unusual review for the Duck, but Why did you bother to post this? Savageduck-(Juggler): That's better. Good grab. You brought in a lot of elements...juggler, balls in the air, kid audience. Savageduck-(Creekside): Very sharp photo and good catch of the man with the smoke behind him, but not a really interesting scene. Bowser-(Adult Club): Anyone who doesn't think the SI can be fun should see this. What a find! It would be nice to see more of the workers. ;-) Bowser-(Helicopter): Nicely done. That image just cries out of HDR Bowser-(?): I wouldn't stand under that. Conway-(Surveyor): Really? Conway-(Construction): Archive shot is one thing, but a scan of a 50s snapshot is stretching it too much. Conway-(Construction2): Ibid. MG-Painter: I like it. The curtain adds a good touch. Browne-Surveyor: Not much here. Browne-Lady Cop: Like Bowser's Adult Club, it's a fun photo. Browne-Flyfishing: Technically what I expect from Alan. After reading the threads on loss of detail at reduced size, I have to wonder if any more detail in the background of trees would add anything to the image. I think not. Richa-(Rug seller): This is the kind of shot I go after. I like the candid catches. Richa-(Camera exchange): Again, I'd do that shot. (And have, but with fewer in the crowd) Well composed for a candid. to me the parties don't seem to be relating to each other. the seller has zero interest in the buyers. Probably telling the photographer not to take his picture. Philo-(Manikin): It's interesting, but it took me too long to figure out what was going on. PeterNewman-Coming Home: I like this kind of shot. The viewer can place himself as the subject. We've all been there. Banks-(Helicopter): Strangely static for the scene. I want some blur on those blades. The best photo in the bunch (IMO) is Alan's fly fishing, but there are several that are more interesting. Does that reflect what we are like as photographers? Do some of us go for the interesting and some of us go for the cover of some magazine? I will not pick a best. the potter and the helicopter are good examples of interesting work shots. The biggest surprise is Peter Newman's. The guy who likes abstracts presents a slice of life photo. Tony Cooper - Sparks The there prosence is there, I owuld have preferred a bit mor subject matter isolation.The light green shadows and turquoise strip are distracting to my eye. Tony cooper - lady barber - why is it necessary to show all the junk in the barber shop/ I am sure why it was included. Tony Cooper the potter. Very well done. We can see his creativity in his interesting hands. Well done. My only nit is the inclusion of the frame in the upper right. -- Peter |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
(SI) People want comments - here's comments! Sounds of the season. | [email protected] | 35mm Photo Equipment | 0 | September 24th 10 03:13 AM |
PSE6: Work-around when Help doesn't work under Windows | John Navas[_2_] | Digital Photography | 3 | January 14th 08 11:04 PM |