If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
[SI] Old stuff comments
Hi,
I still feel that most people here have a lot more knowledge about pictures than I do, but I have now been benefiting from your knowledge since SI 1, so I'll try give my comments this time. Browser: I really like your picture. The colors and the details in the tree stump is just greath. I only would wish that the leaves would have a bit more clear color or at least details. Martin Djernaes: Mine. No comments. Simon Lee: What a funny picture. Old rolls of 35mm film, I guess it's meeting the mandate. Vic Mason: Somehow I find the picture to messy and somehow a bit soft and/or unclear. The plane is really nice and surely isn't new, but somehow it's loosing it's value in the "mess". Somehow the "mess" never makes this picture for me. McLeod: Hmm. Old yes, but I hope not "stuff" ;-) Are there any reason why it's so soft? Ken Nadvornik: What a great photo. The light is really soft and fits very well to the black and white. If I have to find something to ask for, then it would be a bit of detail in the shadow. Brian Fane: What a nice sky color and generally a nice composition. The only thing which bother me in this picture is the splash of brown grass (or what is it?) in the front. Eric Quesnel-Williams: This is such a nice picture. Lot's of nice details in the (top) stamp - I can almost feel the paper. Also the colors from the other stamps below is a great backdrop. Brian Baird: For a while I didn't know what I feelt was wrong with this picture, but now I know. The barn has almost no color, while the trees and grass around is having color. I think this gives this picture an almost mystic feeling. Graham Fountain: Nice picture, but somehow it makes me think about these pictures from the 20'es or so. Doug Payne: Nice seen with the red/rose wheel in the middle. I'm not sure I like the thing (stone?) in front of the first wheel, but else I like the clear detail in the wood. Jim Kramer: Hmm Alan Browne: This is a nice picture, which gives a nice sense of working. Does the blacksmith use his hammer? I would which that I could have seen that more clear in the picture. Christian Gatien: Interesting idea and I think you go a nice result. The fact that I can see the beetle clearly and the roof line is following the curve of the hubcap makes this photo, imho. Al Denelsbeck: Some kind of fossil? Michelo: I don't like the motive, but I think the picture is pretty good. You have lot's of detail in the whole picture, which I find really nice. Bob Hickey: This would have been such a nice picture i I didn't get the feeling that I was looking through some kind of milky glass. Mojtaba Talaian: Is the lap old? I like the modtive, but somehow I think that either the graffiti should have been more colorfull or it shouldn't have been there. Mike Henley: This is a nice picture. Maybe it's not quite what I like, but I think the picture is well done, which a nice balance in the light. The colors on the left of the picture is nice and warm and I almost forget to see the statue, standing in the (cold) shadow. Chibitul: Not only is this an old radio, but it looks like you just found in up under the roof on some old farm ;-) Colm Gallagher: Hmm .. old .. maybe. Details are nice, but I just lack something in that picture. Steve McCartney: This is an interesting picture. Lot's of old feeling in here, but with new (modern) stickers on the windows. I like this picture because of the mood it gives me. That's all folks. Martin |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
[SI] - Entrances & Exits - my comments | Alan Browne | 35mm Photo Equipment | 46 | August 6th 04 08:29 PM |
[SI] Brian's Comments | Brian C. Baird | 35mm Photo Equipment | 10 | July 22nd 04 04:20 PM |
[SI] Local Culture - The Dave comments... | The Dave© | 35mm Photo Equipment | 8 | July 5th 04 04:17 PM |