If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
canon wireless flash setup question
Hi everyone,
I own a canon 10D and a 420ex flash. I'm trying to come up with setup for taking portrait type pictures of hockey players on the ice. Not action shots, but the typical posed 'hockey stance' pictures. I've been doing this with the 10D and the 420ex unit, but I'd like to add more lighting, closer and on an angle. I already bought a stroboframe flash bracket but I haven't picked up the off-camera shoe cord yet. (you'll see why this matters below). I see two solutions and I'm not sure which is best. Solution #1, add: - 550EX (it can control my 420EX as a slave) - off-camera shoe cord (for the stroboframe bracket) Solution #2, add: - ST-E2 wireless transmitter (to control both 420ex's) - another 420EX Both solutions allow me to use two light sources, but with solution #1 one of the light sources is limited to being on the camera, so straight on. With solution #2 I could place the 420EX's on different angles and control them with the ST-E2 transmitter. BTW, both options end up costing about the same $$. I would appreciate any thoughts on this, or even alternate solutions. Thanks, Chris |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Chris
I went through the same thought processes about a year ago (with an Elan 7e instead of your 10D). I ended up purchasing a ST-E2 and 550ex to use with my 420ex. I almost bought another 420ex (instead of the 550ex), but thought the extra flash power might be handy when using the flash by itself (I'm glad I did). It's funny.... My first 2 solutions were the same as yours, even down the "same money" part. Then I came up with option #3, ST-E2 & 550ex. I've been very happy with the results. Hope this helps Rob www.rcp.ca Hi Rob, First of all, what superb photos you have on your website. Just beautiful. I love the dynamic range you capture. And I can't believe you have a DOF chart there, I was just looking for that! So, do you find the ST-E2 has an acceptable range? I read that the 550ex can control the salve flash units at a much greater distance. Having said that, I don't think I'll ever need to be that far away from the slave units. Thanks, Chris |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 09 Feb 2005 06:20:59 -0800, Chris wrote:
Hi everyone, I own a canon 10D and a 420ex flash. I'm trying to come up with setup for taking portrait type pictures of hockey players on the ice. Not action shots, but the typical posed 'hockey stance' pictures. I've been doing this with the 10D and the 420ex unit, but I'd like to add more lighting, closer and on an angle. I already bought a stroboframe flash bracket but I haven't picked up the off-camera shoe cord yet. (you'll see why this matters below). I see two solutions and I'm not sure which is best. Solution #1, add: - 550EX (it can control my 420EX as a slave) - off-camera shoe cord (for the stroboframe bracket) Solution #2, add: - ST-E2 wireless transmitter (to control both 420ex's) - another 420EX Both solutions allow me to use two light sources, but with solution #1 one of the light sources is limited to being on the camera, so straight on. With solution #2 I could place the 420EX's on different angles and control them with the ST-E2 transmitter. BTW, both options end up costing about the same $$. I would appreciate any thoughts on this, or even alternate solutions. Thanks, Chris When I still used Canon EOS equipment I had the same setup (550, 420, ST-E2) and found it worked okay on my D60, but in all honesty the results using E-TTL varied quite a lot and were not reliable enough for what I was doing in portraiture. This may have been a fault of the D60's meter. Who knows... IMO the 420EX is a ****ty product from Canon simply because of its limited modes - well lack of anything other than E-TTL. I wouldn't ever recommend it to anyone. Your first solution would be better, but it is also limited in that the slave on the 550EX only works in E-TTL mode. My advice is to sell the 420 EX and get a couple of manual flashes with a slave (Vivitar 283's are good). Use one of the flashes on camera and the other can be placed off-camera with the slave. Get yourself a decent flash meter and set everything manually. -- Save photography - shoot a roll of film today! |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Roxy d'Urban wrote in message ...
When I still used Canon EOS equipment I had the same setup (550, 420, ST-E2) and found it worked okay on my D60, but in all honesty the results using E-TTL varied quite a lot and were not reliable enough for what I was doing in portraiture. This may have been a fault of the D60's meter. Who knows... IMO the 420EX is a ****ty product from Canon simply because of its limited modes - well lack of anything other than E-TTL. I wouldn't ever recommend it to anyone. Your first solution would be better, but it is also limited in that the slave on the 550EX only works in E-TTL mode. My advice is to sell the 420 EX and get a couple of manual flashes with a slave (Vivitar 283's are good). Use one of the flashes on camera and the other can be placed off-camera with the slave. Get yourself a decent flash meter and set everything manually. I have some control over the 420ex output by using my camera's onboard FEC, and I think that will still work in slave mode. However if the e-ttl results are varied, then that is a problem. I've been reading up on the vivitar 283 (with slave) and that does look apealing, much less expensive anyway. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 14 Feb 2005 15:18:38 -0800, Chris wrote:
Roxy d'Urban wrote in message ... When I still used Canon EOS equipment I had the same setup (550, 420, ST-E2) and found it worked okay on my D60, but in all honesty the results using E-TTL varied quite a lot and were not reliable enough for what I was doing in portraiture. This may have been a fault of the D60's meter. Who knows... IMO the 420EX is a ****ty product from Canon simply because of its limited modes - well lack of anything other than E-TTL. I wouldn't ever recommend it to anyone. Your first solution would be better, but it is also limited in that the slave on the 550EX only works in E-TTL mode. My advice is to sell the 420 EX and get a couple of manual flashes with a slave (Vivitar 283's are good). Use one of the flashes on camera and the other can be placed off-camera with the slave. Get yourself a decent flash meter and set everything manually. I have some control over the 420ex output by using my camera's onboard FEC, and I think that will still work in slave mode. However if the e-ttl results are varied, then that is a problem. I've been reading up on the vivitar 283 (with slave) and that does look apealing, much less expensive anyway. When I had an EOS system I always only used the wireless E-TTL with the D60 (previously the D30) and never with film. The results indigital were quite varied, depending on what I was doing. One area that I had a lot of problems with using this system was in the white balance area. I photographed some products for my company brochure and the colours were way off, regardless of the white balance setting used. Another problem was exposure. Whilst the majority of the shots were correctly exposed, every so often I would get a completely flummoxed shot - usually underexposed by about two or three stops. I think a lot of this has to do with the way E-TTL works using the pre-flash system - it's certainly not foolproof. In my view, if you are happy to use a flash meter with manually fired 283's (or any other flash in manual mode) your results will be a lot better because you will be in control of exposure, not the camera. -- Save photography - shoot a roll of film today! |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
When I had an EOS system I always only used the wireless E-TTL with the
D60 (previously the D30) and never with film. The results indigital were quite varied, depending on what I was doing. One area that I had a lot of I've said this several times before, but, particularly if you have the latitude afforded by modern film of digicams, a manual flash is the only way to go. E-TTL doesn't seem to offer any real improvements over an electric-eye flash, and E-TTL flashes are not only more expensive, but they are less versatile. -Joel ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Please feed the 35mm lens/digicam databases: http://www.exc.com/photography ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Chris
You're right, the st-e2 does a shorter range than a 550ex but I haven't found it to be a problem. Although, I'm usually indoors when using mutiple flashes & st-e2 combo. Rob www.rcp.ca wrote: Hi Chris I went through the same thought processes about a year ago (with an Elan 7e instead of your 10D). I ended up purchasing a ST-E2 and 550ex to use with my 420ex. I almost bought another 420ex (instead of the 550ex), but thought the extra flash power might be handy when using the flash by itself (I'm glad I did). It's funny.... My first 2 solutions were the same as yours, even down the "same money" part. Then I came up with option #3, ST-E2 & 550ex. I've been very happy with the results. Hope this helps Rob www.rcp.ca Hi Rob, First of all, what superb photos you have on your website. Just beautiful. I love the dynamic range you capture. And I can't believe you have a DOF chart there, I was just looking for that! So, do you find the ST-E2 has an acceptable range? I read that the 550ex can control the salve flash units at a much greater distance. Having said that, I don't think I'll ever need to be that far away from the slave units. Thanks, Chris |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
flash slave for canon A85? | Gaderian | Digital Photography | 10 | January 21st 05 12:19 AM |
Help Choosing Canon 20D Setup (Body, lenses, flash, etc) | A | Digital Photography | 24 | November 16th 04 11:45 PM |
Help Choosing Canon 20D Setup (Body, lenses, flash, etc) | A | 35mm Photo Equipment | 23 | November 16th 04 11:45 PM |
Canon S1 IS flash card compatibility | [email protected] | Digital Photography | 6 | June 29th 04 12:54 AM |
Basic Minolta flash questions | Dave Yuhas | 35mm Photo Equipment | 5 | June 28th 04 05:05 PM |