If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
Hi all -
I just heard about the Canon online 400D competiton. I've entered a pic in it he http://www.canon.com.au/eos400d/Gall...?imageid=19622 It's my first competition!!! If anyone thinks it's worthy of a vote, please do! It goes for a week starting today. Constructive comments would also be welcomed. (I use Picasa to edit, so it brings up noise more quickly than a professional package would). Many thanks, Mick |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
"schM1ck 1" wrote in message ups.com... Hi all - I just heard about the Canon online 400D competiton. I've entered a pic in it he http://www.canon.com.au/eos400d/Gall...?imageid=19622 It's my first competition!!! If anyone thinks it's worthy of a vote, please do! It goes for a week starting today. Constructive comments would also be welcomed. (I use Picasa to edit, so it brings up noise more quickly than a professional package would). Many thanks, Mick I personally am not particularly taken by it, bit busy and not particularly crisp. I am not very familiar with Picasa but I suspect that it is not the best package around to get the best from your photos. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
schM1ck 1 wrote:
I just heard about the Canon online 400D competiton. I've entered a pic in it he http://www.canon.com.au/eos400d/Gall...?imageid=19622 It's my first competition!!! --- Constructive comments would also be welcomed. (I use Picasa to edit, so it brings up noise more quickly than a professional package would). Comment given in with positive intentions: This photo has got the elements to make more. Its in a way a bit halfway photo, it does not make the idea strongly clear. A photo must usually pint clearly out its idea, and the birds in foreground remain too tame for that. The contrasts of night look good on my LCD display. Its too easy to make a night scene almost photo graphics. Olli Orkoneva |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
Pete D wrote: not particularly crisp. I am not very familiar with Picasa but I suspect that it is not the best package around to get the best from your photos. *grin* it's not. But it's what I know. So... you play around with what your abilities allow you to do. I've tried PS-ing it, but I'm nowhere near skilled enough to bring the best elements out and make it shine. So I make do. Thanks for your thoughts Pete. - Mick |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
Olli wrote: This photo has got the elements to make more. Its in a way a bit halfway photo, it does not make the idea strongly clear. A photo must usually pint clearly out its idea, and the birds in foreground remain too tame for that. The contrasts of night look good on my LCD display. Its too easy to make a night scene almost photo graphics. Olli Orkoneva Fair enough. What elements have potential, and can I ask what you mean by 'tame'? (Should they heve been viciously devouring dolphins or whales? JK!) Cheers, - Mick |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
schM1ck 1 wrote:
Hi all - I just heard about the Canon online 400D competiton. I've entered a pic in it he http://www.canon.com.au/eos400d/Gall...?imageid=19622 It's my first competition!!! If anyone thinks it's worthy of a vote, please do! It goes for a week starting today. Constructive comments would also be welcomed. (I use Picasa to edit, so it brings up noise more quickly than a professional package would). Many thanks, Mick I like to see a story and what I see is two subjects. The bridge and skyline is fine, nicely done. The two birds are fine. However I don't see a connection, rather I see competing subjects neither of which is supporting the other. I might have liked it better without the starcross effect and maybe a little closer to the birds. Then the birds might have taken control of the image. That said, the technical part of the photo (exposure contrast etc.) is very good and is not all that easy a subject to get it good. -- Joseph Meehan Dia 's Muire duit |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
schM1ck 1 wrote:
This photo has got the elements to make more. Its in a way a bit halfway photo, it does not make the idea strongly clear. A photo must usually pint clearly out its idea, and the birds in foreground remain too tame for that. Fair enough. What elements have potential, and can I ask what you mean by 'tame'? (Should they heve been viciously devouring dolphins or whales? JK!) I think that the foreground elements should be more dominating. There is some examples he http://www.cameraontheroad.com/index.php?p=233 I see that your idea is to get both foreground and background into pic, but they are too equal. As you usually make the best photos when you make them for a specific purpose, you can start thinking what is the purpose of this pic. Think about it as an illustration for a newspaper or magazine story telling about this place OR the statue in foreground. If you decide what you want to tell, its easier to figure out how you could improve the pic. Think of the pic recomposed so that the statue gets higher. First 1/6 of the height of the pic. Then so much that it comes on the horizontal lines of the bridge. I know that my starting point can be very different of yours, since I comment your pics as journalist (and amateur photographer), but you can read my comments knowing my background. Olli Orkoneva |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
On Tue, 14 Nov 2006 12:55:00 GMT, "Joseph Meehan"
wrote: schM1ck 1 wrote: Hi all - I just heard about the Canon online 400D competiton. I've entered a pic in it he http://www.canon.com.au/eos400d/Gall...?imageid=19622 It's my first competition!!! If anyone thinks it's worthy of a vote, please do! It goes for a week starting today. Constructive comments would also be welcomed. (I use Picasa to edit, so it brings up noise more quickly than a professional package would). Many thanks, Mick I like to see a story and what I see is two subjects. The bridge and skyline is fine, nicely done. The two birds are fine. However I don't see a connection, rather I see competing subjects neither of which is supporting the other. I might have liked it better without the starcross effect and maybe a little closer to the birds. Then the birds might have taken control of the image. That said, the technical part of the photo (exposure contrast etc.) is very good and is not all that easy a subject to get it good. Was this photo actually taken with a 300D on 1/01/1980 or does the date in the camera need setting? Jack Mac |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
"schM1ck 1" wrote in message ups.com... Hi all - I just heard about the Canon online 400D competiton. I've entered a pic in it he http://www.canon.com.au/eos400d/Gall...?imageid=19622 It's my first competition!!! If anyone thinks it's worthy of a vote, please do! It goes for a week starting today. Constructive comments would also be welcomed. (I use Picasa to edit, so it brings up noise more quickly than a professional package would). Many thanks, Mick I think you would have a very nice photo if you would remove the birds. When I look at your photo my eye is drawn to the lights on the bridge, the lights from the buildings and the reflections on the water. The birds are a distraction, it's like they don't belong with the rest of the scene. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
What to you think of my first competition photo?
On 14 Nov 2006 04:26:22 -0800, "schM1ck 1"
wrote: I've tried PS-ing it, but I'm nowhere near skilled enough to bring the best elements out and make it shine. I highly recommend Photoshop For Digital Photographers by Scott Kelby. He has editions of this book for several different Photoshop and Photoshop Elements versions so get the edition that matches your software. After I learned how to make certain edits I found many of my photos benefitted from those edits. jc -- "The nice thing about a mare is you get to ride a lot of different horses without having to own that many." ~ Eileen Morgan of The Mare's Nest, PA |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
digital photo competition software | Roy Moore | Digital Photography | 2 | December 30th 05 02:20 PM |
Shuttertalk Photo Competition: Win a 1G memory card! | Julian Tan | Digital Photography | 3 | March 1st 05 02:44 AM |
portrait photo competition | Jase | Photographing People | 2 | December 6th 04 12:47 AM |
Daily Telegraph Photo Competition | Mike O'sullivan | Digital Photography | 9 | June 26th 04 09:09 PM |
Digital Dreams - UK photo competition | Slush | Digital Photo Equipment For Sale | 0 | September 16th 03 05:34 PM |