If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Megapixel envy?
Everything I've read about the Panasonic Lumix FZ5, FZ20, and the Canon
Powershot S2 IS -- indicates a fairly high degree of noise above ISO 100. I think this comes from the signal-to-noise issue of trying to cram 5MPs of data onto the same 1/2.5 sensor that Panasonic has used as far back as my FZ1. Love the lens. Hate the 2MP limitation. However, still available and offering a fairly vast degree of user features is the Panasonic FZ15, a 4-MP "little brother" of the FZ20. Costs a bit less than any of the other three cameras. The FZ15 has a constant f2.8 aperture across the zoom range, TIFF option, manual focus override, but no audio on video clips and no external flash support (although I seldom use flash on the FZ1). Given that most of my long-range FZ1 photos are indoor shots (my kids in concerts, swim meets, and plays), will the difference between 4 and 5 MP really hurt me? What do you think? _Cardamon Dave |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Cardamon Dave wrote:
[] Given that most of my long-range FZ1 photos are indoor shots (my kids in concerts, swim meets, and plays), will the difference between 4 and 5 MP really hurt me? What do you think? It's 25% in area, so that's a 12% increase is linear resolution. Just perhaps the lower noise of the 4MP sensor (if that really is the case) and the larger aperture (f/2.8 versus f/3.3) _might_ make a difference on a few shots. If movies are important to you, the Canon S2 IS is the best right now. In the Panasonic range, I would go for the newer FZ5 camera with its better image processing. Yes, stick to ISO 100 if you can, but occasionally the added noise (grain) of the higher ISO shots can add to the character. Cheers, David |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks David. Movies aren't important, although I occasionally do
capture short clips. Is the FZ5's processor that much faster than the FZ15's? I suppose I can pull down the noise in low-light shots with software. But I also use the FZ1 camera with an ND or IR (Hoya) filter for longer exposures, where grain/noise would be a given. I've noticed a few people who sell their FZ20s online, saying they're making the jump to DSLRs. I don't really feel I'd get my money's worth out of a DSLR, given how quickly new models supercede current ones. (Nikon's D70 had a 1-year life before the D70s emerged.) For my money, it's all about the lens -- and the Leica on the FZ series has really been a classy performer. _Cardamon Dave |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Cardamon Dave wrote:
Thanks David. Movies aren't important, although I occasionally do capture short clips. Is the FZ5's processor that much faster than the FZ15's? I haven't used an FZ15 so I can't say from experience, but I understand you do notice the improved speed. I suppose I can pull down the noise in low-light shots with software. But I also use the FZ1 camera with an ND or IR (Hoya) filter for longer exposures, where grain/noise would be a given. Most cameras have dark-frame subtraction which should reduce the effect of bad pixels on longer exposures. I'm pretty certain the FZ5 does this automatically (probably not in "simple" or "programmed" mode, just in aperture- and shutter-priority modes. I've noticed a few people who sell their FZ20s online, saying they're making the jump to DSLRs. I don't really feel I'd get my money's worth out of a DSLR, given how quickly new models supercede current ones. (Nikon's D70 had a 1-year life before the D70s emerged.) For my money, it's all about the lens -- and the Leica on the FZ series has really been a classy performer. For me, the bulk and weight of the DSLR and its lenses and accessories would be the deciding factor - I used to have Nikon 35mm SLRs but they ended up staying at home. The cost is another factor. The good thing is that you can keep the lenses between bodies (but just look at the cost of a lens equivalent to the one on your FZ1!). Cheers, David |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
5 Megapixel VS. 4 Megapixel camera | Mark | Digital Photography | 13 | March 9th 05 04:06 PM |
megapixel, sensor-size and pixelsize | Fr@nk | Digital Photography | 10 | January 17th 05 03:42 AM |
megapixel, sensor-size and pixelsize | Fr@nk | Digital Photography | 0 | January 9th 05 05:51 PM |
Cheap 5.25 megapixel - Bargain? | BUB 209 | Digital Photography | 3 | September 25th 04 07:40 AM |
5 megapixel camera suggestion | Anna | Digital Photography | 26 | July 2nd 04 04:59 AM |