CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

Hello,

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two
cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be controlled by
the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large display, while the S3 does
not. Which one should I buy? They are priced almost the same. Thank you.

T.I.

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

"Talal Itani" wrote in
news:k5dsg.5239$Ep.1907@trnddc08:
I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to
two cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be
controlled by the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large
display, while the S3 does not. Which one should I buy? They are
priced almost the same. Thank you.

The Canon LCD folds out, which is a very nice feature when you're taking
pictures at odd angles (e.g., over a crowd or at ground level).

This review compares the image quaility of the H5 and S3 (and a few
others): http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/SonyH5/
They do conclude that the H5 is not much better than the much cheaper H2.

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

Talal Itani wrote:

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two
cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be controlled by

Since neither is an SLR, please keep the discussion off of the
..slr-systems group.

Cheers,
Alan

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

I took a quick look at the Canon S3-IS and the Sony H2.
I found the eyepiece electronic finder unacceptably unsharp
even with my best efforts to focus the eyepiece; the Sony's
finder is considerably better. I would consider the H2 over
the H5 for its lower image noise levels (the images are otherwise
similar, so why pay the extra?).
--
David Ruether


http://www.ferrario.com/ruether


----- Original Message -----
From: "Talal Itani"
Newsgroups: news.misc.photo.digital,rec.photo.digital,rec.phot o.digital.point+shoot,rec.photo.digital.slr-systems
Sent: Sunday, July 09, 2006 3:49 PM
Subject: CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?


Hello,

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be
controlled by the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large display, while the S3 does not. Which one should I buy? They are
priced almost the same. Thank you.

T.I.

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

"David Ruether" wrote in message
news:Vl%Fg.1159$HW1.798@trndny03...
I took a quick look at the Canon S3-IS and the Sony H2.
I found the eyepiece electronic finder unacceptably unsharp
even with my best efforts to focus the eyepiece; the Sony's
finder is considerably better. I would consider the H2 over
the H5 for its lower image noise levels (the images are otherwise
similar, so why pay the extra?).
--

AS far as i know, H2 has lower noise becasue of different noise reduction
program, which however is not as good as one in H5. If you read reviews, as
one in dpreview.com, i think that conclusion is that S3 still has nicer
picture, more even in colors, etc... read one article about comparing S3, H5
and panasonic FZ7 - note especially shot at ISO800 made wth FZ7 - noise
reduction is so strong that pic is quite useless...

David Ruether


http://www.ferrario.com/ruether


----- Original Message -----
From: "Talal Itani"
Newsgroups:
news.misc.photo.digital,rec.photo.digital,rec.phot o.digital.point+shoot,rec.photo.digital.slr-systems
Sent: Sunday, July 09, 2006 3:49 PM
Subject: CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?


Hello,

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two
cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be controlled by
the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large display, while the S3
does not. Which one should I buy? They are priced almost the same.
Thank you.

T.I.

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

Two things I hate about the H5, although it may be a better overall camera
than the Canon, are the much larger bulky size, and the Sony "only" memory
stick.

David, I am in the same boat as you. I can't quiet decide on the Canon,
Sony, or the panasonic. I'm leaning towards the Canon, but haven't handled
the Panasonic. One drawback on the FZ7 is it only uses the rechargable
battery from Panasonic.


"Protoncek (ex.SleeperMan)" wrote in message
...

"David Ruether" wrote in message
news:Vl%Fg.1159$HW1.798@trndny03...
I took a quick look at the Canon S3-IS and the Sony H2.
I found the eyepiece electronic finder unacceptably unsharp
even with my best efforts to focus the eyepiece; the Sony's
finder is considerably better. I would consider the H2 over
the H5 for its lower image noise levels (the images are otherwise
similar, so why pay the extra?).
--

AS far as i know, H2 has lower noise becasue of different noise reduction
program, which however is not as good as one in H5. If you read reviews, as
one in dpreview.com, i think that conclusion is that S3 still has nicer
picture, more even in colors, etc... read one article about comparing S3, H5
and panasonic FZ7 - note especially shot at ISO800 made wth FZ7 - noise
reduction is so strong that pic is quite useless...

David Ruether


http://www.ferrario.com/ruether


----- Original Message -----
From: "Talal Itani"
Newsgroups:

news.misc.photo.digital,rec.photo.digital,rec.phot o.digital.point+shoot,rec.
photo.digital.slr-systems
Sent: Sunday, July 09, 2006 3:49 PM
Subject: CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?


Hello,

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two
cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be controlled by
the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large display, while the S3
does not. Which one should I buy? They are priced almost the same.
Thank you.

T.I.

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

----- Original Message -----
From: "Talal Itani"
Newsgroups: news.misc.photo.digital,rec.photo.digital,rec.phot o.digital.point+shoot,rec.photo.digital.slr-systems
Sent: Sunday, July 09, 2006 3:49 PM
Subject: CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?


Hello,

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can be
controlled by the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large display, while the S3 does not. Which one should I buy? They are
priced almost the same. Thank you.

T.I.


compare here,:
http://www.digitalcamerainfo.com/con...ge-Quality.htm

CANON S3 or SONY H5 ?
 

wrote in message oups.com...

Hello,

I am shopping for a digital camera. I narrowed down my search to two cameras: The Sony Canon S3 and the Sony H5. The S3 can
be
controlled by the PC, while the H5 cannot. The H5 has a large display, while the S3 does not. Which one should I buy? They
are
priced almost the same. Thank you.

T.I.

compare here,:
http://www.digitalcamerainfo.com/con...ge-Quality.htm

Nice comparison (too bad it didn't include the Sony H2...).
Still, the softer viewfinder of the Canon compared with the
Sony tilts it toward the Sony for me. If you can't see in the
finder what you are getting (except for framing, but not
sharpness/focus-point), well, what's the point of some
other minor advantages...? ;-) As I said before, the H2
likely has some image advantages over the H5, in addition
to lower price - but all of the cameras included in the test
are good cameras (the OP wouldn't do badly choosing
any of these, plus a few more...).
--
David Ruether


http://www.ferrario.com/ruether